The Truth About Pillow Fillings: Which One is Right for You?

The Truth About Pillow Fillings: Which One is Right for You?

Let’s be honest—choosing the right pillow can feel a little overwhelming. Soft or firm? Fluffy or flat? And what’s actually inside these things?

At Pillows and Fibers, we’ve been making pillows long enough to know that what’s inside matters just as much as how it feels on the outside. So let’s break down the most popular (and practical) pillow fillings we offer, so you can find the one that suits your sleep style.

Down and Feather Fill

What it is: A mix of down (the soft stuff under the feathers) and feathers from ducks or geese.

Best for: People who want a classic, hotel-style pillow with a soft, luxurious feel.

The truth: Down and feather pillows are plush, breathable, and moldable. They're perfect if you love a pillow that you can squish and fluff into the perfect shape. Just keep in mind—they may not be the best for allergy sufferers unless you go with a hypoallergenic option.

🌱 Polyester Fiber (Poly-Fill)

What it is: Synthetic fiber made from polyester—affordable, versatile, and vegan-friendly. Best for: Sleepers who want a medium to firm feel and a low-maintenance pillow.

The truth: Poly-fill is our go-to for a reason. It holds its shape, it’s budget-friendly, and it doesn’t trap allergens. Whether you sleep on your back, side, or stomach, we’ve got a poly-fill blend that’ll work for you.

🧺 Gel Fiber and Microfiber

What it is: Superfine synthetic fibers that mimic the feel of down, often with added cooling features.

Best for: Anyone who wants softness without the feathers.

The truth: These pillows are soft, breathable, and great for people with allergies. Gel fiber, in particular, adds a cooling touch—perfect if you tend to sleep warm but don’t want to shell out for pricier specialty pillows.

So...Which Filling Is Your Match?

• If you’re all about that classic, luxury feel: Down & feather

• If you need something practical and easy to care for: Poly-fill

• If you want soft and cool, without the allergens: Gel fiber or microfiber

Sleep Better, Choose Smarter

Whatever your sleep style, we believe the right pillow filling can make all the difference. At

Pillows and Fibers, we’ve got options to match your comfort preferences, your budget, and your lifestyle. Still not sure? Reach out—we're happy to help you find your perfect fit.

Sleep happy,The Pillows and Fibers Team